Tuesday, June 16, 2026

Talks on Aparoksanubhuti (very loose transcreations)

16

According to this Shankaracharya, I am the One as the subtle and the knower, the witness, immutable existence.

It's like a ladder to the Fourth. The subtle is the mind and the knower is reflected consciousness. The witness is awareness. Immutable existence is unborn.

Like pure consciousness is the sun, the knower is the moon, and the mind is moonlight illuminating earth. Further, the principle of existence transcends this big bang of spacetime.

17.

Atman is without parts, one.

The body has many many parts.

Yet you see these two as one!

What lunacy is greater than this?

19.

Atman is pure consciousness.

The body is a mess of flesh and bone.

Yet you see these two as one!

What lunacy is greater than this?

20.

Atman is the absolute illuminator.

The body is dark and inert.

Yet you see these two as one!

What lunacy is greater than this?

21.

Atman is that timeless principle of existence.

The body is constantly changing so it never actually exists.

Yet you see these two as one!

What lunacy is greater than this?

22-24

The light of Atman illumines all. And unlike with the light of a fire or flashlight, that Self sees both the presence and absence of light.

Because of beginningless ignorance, people think they are the body-mind. It's like the maker mistaking they're the pot.

I am Brahman alone, the self-contained, calm sea of satcitananda. I am not an unreal waveform. This is what the wise call real knowledge.

25-28

Changeless, formless, faultless, I am truly imperishable. This is what the wise call real knowledge.

Afflictionless, reflectionless, conceptionless, I am all-pervading. This is what the wise call real knowledge.

Conditionless, actionless, endless, I am unbound. This is what the wise call real knowledge.

Immaculate, immovable, unadulterated, I am ageless and immortal. This is what the wise call real knowledge.

31

That supreme I is one alone. Material and one of many, how can the mere physical body be the Self?

32

It's well-established that I is the seer and the body is the seen. Thus they say, this is mine. So how can a mere body be the Self?

33

That I is changeless and the body is always changing. This is visibly experienced. So how can a mere body be the Self?

39

Even the subtle body is made of unstable parts. It too is an object, subject to modification, limited, and unreal. So how can it be the Self?

40

Different from these two bodies is Atman, Purusa, Isvara, the Self of all, of all form and beyond all, that imperishable I.

43

In the one Consciousness, there can be no division. All individuality is in vain. It's as a snake mistakenly seen in the rope.

44

From an ignorance of the rope comes the appearance of a snake. Similarly, in pure immutable consciousness appears a phenomenal universe.

45

The substrate of the universe is Brahman. There's nothing other than that there. Thus, the whole universe is Brahman only.

49

All beings are born of Brahman, Paramatman. Therefore one should understand they are Brahman alone.

50

All various names and forms are Brahman alone. All activity is similarly sustained. This is divine revelation.

51

Whatever's created from gold is always gold. And too, whoever is born of Brahman is always of the nature of Brahman.

52

Imagining the slightest difference between an individual self and the Supreme Self is the undertaking of a foolish mind and certain to invite much fear and loathing.

53

As reality is misconceived, duality appears—and one sees another. But as one is seeing the Self in all, there is no other in the least.

54

In the one who truly realizes all beings as the Self, there's neither delusion nor sorrow, for there is no second.

56

However much an experience this practical transactional world seems to be, it is unsubstantial like a dream with all its momentary contradictions.

57

Upon waking, the dream state disappears. In dreaming, there is no waking state. Both are non-existent in deep sleep while deep sleep is unavailable in both.

58

Thus these three states are considered to be unreal, creations of the three primal attributes. The real seer is beyond all attributes, that one consciousness, the Self.

104.

All is Brahman. From this understanding, the senses are self-controlled.

This approach is called authentic yama and should be cultivated again and again.

105.

The continuous current of that thought (I am Brahman) while excluding dissimilar thoughts

is called true niyama, which is supreme bliss and a regular observance by the wise.

106.

Renunciation of the phenomenal world by seeing it as the Atman of pure consciousness

is real renunciation and worshipped by the great ones as instant liberation.

107.

From where words turn back unable to reach the mind

is that silence attainable by yogis but which the realized one always is.

108.

Who can speak of that from which all words return?

Just to describe this phenomenal world is beyond all words.

109.

Let that silence of the wise be known as the natural state.

The silence of words is merely prescribed for the unknowing by the knowers of Brahman.

110.

Where the world does not exist, in the beginning, middle, or end,

is that all-pervading space only solitude knows.

111.

In the blink of an eye, Time produces all beings, beginning with Brahma the Creator.

Verily that is also called Timeless, the one who is unbroken bliss and nondual.

112.

That way in which unbroken meditation on Brahman flows with ease

is the right posture. And not some other Asana which destroys one's equanimity.

113.

That known as the source of all beings, the substrate of the universe, the immutable ground

upon which the enlightened one is seated — that truly is the perfect posture.


created 10/18/25 to 12/1/25


Monday, June 15, 2026

A Nondual Creed

1. Consciousness is not a product of the body-mind. 

2. Consciousness is the ground upon which the body-mind is superimposed. 

3. Consciousness is the noumenal absolute called Brahman. 

4. The universe appears in Brahman. 

5. The universe is of Brahman. 

6. Brahman is all there is.

7. Nondual Brahman is consciousness-existence called Satcitananda.

8. I, Atman, am Brahman, is Turiyam.

Aum

Sunday, June 14, 2026

Transcreating Dakshinamurti 8


Translations

viśvaṁ paśyati kārya-kāraṇa-tayā sva-svāmi-sambandhataḥ śiṣyācārya-tayā tathaiva pitṛ-putrādyātmanā bhedataḥ, svapne jāgrati vā ya eṣa puruṣo māyā-paribhrāmitaḥ tasmai śrī-guru-mūrtaye nama idaṁ śrī-dakṣiṇāmūrtaye. 

(8) विश्वं – world; पश्यति – sees; कार्यकारणतया – of cause and effect; स्वस्वामिसम्बन्धतः – as the relationship of possessions and the possessor; शिष्याचार्यतया – as the taught and the Teacher; तथा - similarly; एव – also; पितृपुत्राद्यात्मना – as father and son in himself; भेदतः – differentiation; स्वप्ने – in dream; जाग्रति – in waking; वा – or; यः – He who; एषः – this; पुरुषः – Puruṣa; मायापरिभ्रामितः – whirled in māyā; तस्मै – to Him; श्रीगुरुमूर्तये – the divine Teacher; नमः – prostration; इदं – this; श्रीदक्षिणामूर्तये – to Śrī Dakṣiṇāmūrti 

8. He, who is the Puruṣa, whirled in māyā, sees the world of cause-effect, diversely related as possessor and possession, father and son and as Teacher and taught, both in the state of waking and dreaming; to Him, the divine Teacher, Śrī Dakṣiṇāmūrti, is this prostration. ~Chinmayananda

To the Self who, deluded by mayā sees, in dream-ing and waking, the universe in its distinctions such as cause and effect, property and proprietor, disciple and teacher, and father and son, likewise to Him, of the form of the Preceptor, the blessed Dakshina-murti may this obeisance be! ~Mahadevan

8. Obeisance to Śri Daksināmūrti, who is the Guru, (who as) this person, being deluded by māyā sees the world both in sleep and in the waking state, as (full of) differences (brought about by such) relationships as cause and effect, property and owner, disciple and teacher as also father, mother and so on. ~Harshananda

To the Atman who, deluded by Mâyâ, sees, in jâgrat or svapna, the universe in variety, as cause and effect, as master and servant, as teacher and disciple, as father and son, and so on to Him who is incarnate in the Teacher, to Him in the Effulgent Form Facing the South, to Him (Siva) be this bow! ~Sastri


My transcreation in progress:

The world is seen as cause and effect, possessor and possession, student and teacher. 

Similarly division takes on the selves of parent and child.

In dreams or in the waking state, individuals are thoroughly deluded by Maya.


Google search:

Word-by-word (Line 1):
  • viśvam: The universe / the world
  • paśyati: Sees
  • kārya-kāraṇa-tayā: As cause and effect
  • sva-svāmi-sambandhataḥ: As the owner and the owned (master and servant)
  • śiṣyācārya-tayā: As the student (disciple) and the teacher (master)
  • tathaiva: Similarly / in the same manner
  • pitṛ-putra-ādi-ātmanā: In the form of father, son, and others
  • bhedataḥ: In a state of plurality/division (duality)
Word-by-word (Line 2):
  • svapne: In dreams
  • jāgrati: In the waking state
  • vā: Or
  • yaḥ eṣaḥ: This
  • puruṣaḥ: Person (individual)
  • māyā-paribhrāmitaḥ: Deluded / thoroughly bewildered by illusion
  • tasmai: To Him
  • śrī-guru-mūrtaye: To the embodiment of the Guru
  • namaḥ: Salutations / prostrations
  • idam: This
  • śrī-dakṣiṇāmūrtaye: To Lord Dakṣiṇāmūrti



Saturday, June 13, 2026

Heresies in the Material World 1

The seer itself, the sky-like supreme; ever-shining and changeless, one alone and unborn; stainless, all-pervading, nondual. 
~Shankara, from US-V10.1


1. Consciousness

a. Consciousness is not a product of the material world in general, and of the body-mind in particular. 

b. Consciousness is the ground upon which the body-mind is super-imposed.

c. Consciousness is the noumenal absolute godhead nondual Brahman. 

d. The universe appears in Brahman. The universe is of Brahman. Brahman is all there is.

d1. As dreamstates appear in the mind, and dreams are of the mind, and the mind is in and of nondual consciousness.

I minus unawareness equals awareness. Aum.

2. Dreamstates

The waking dream state seems real because it appears in and of unchanging consciousness which is as real as it gets.

The sleeping dream state appears real for a moment because it appears in and of the changing mind.

3. Elementary

Understanding the metaphysics of Advaita is like knowing the floor you're standing on is 99.9% space—

like indirect (paroksha) to direct (aparoksha), like the difference between physicist and sage.

4. Am I

Am I the body-mind which is nothing without Brahman or am I Atman, Brahman, in which nothing but dreams appear?

Am I a body-mind reflecting consciousness or am I consciousness reflecting in a body-mind? That is the real question.





Nondual Creed

1. Consciousness is not a product of the body-mind. 

2. Consciousness is the ground upon which the body-mind is superimposed. 

3. Consciousness is the noumenal absolute called Brahman. 

4. The universe appears in Brahman. 

5. The universe is of Brahman. 

6. Brahman is all there is.

7. Nondual Brahman is consciousness-existence called Satcitananda.

8. I, Atman, am Brahman, is Turiyam.

Aum





Friday, June 12, 2026

Transcreating Shankara's Upadesa Sahasri Verse Chapter 10 dṛśi-svarūpa paramārtha-darśanam


1. 

The seer itself, the sky-like supreme;

ever-shining and changeless, one alone and unborn;

stainless, all-pervading, nondual:

thus I am that eternally released. Om.


2.

I am the seer, pure and unchanging.

By my very nature, there aren't any objects to me.

Before and behind, above and below, everywhere is 

the all-pervading reality, unborn and abiding as the Self.


3.

Unborn, undying, and accordingly ageless,

deathless, self-luminous, and all-pervasive, I am nondual—

neither cause nor effect, impeccably pure, 

and ever content in complete liberation. Om.


4.

Deep sleep, the waking state, and the dream state are not my experiences

and do not exist for me at all, like illusions.

They neither exist independently nor are they dependent on the real. 

Thus I am always the Fourth alone, the nondual seer.


5.

The continuous suffering of body, intellect, and the senses are not mine

and I'm not theirs, for I am changeless

and also because of the unreality of this stream.

It's unreal like the dreamlike visions of a sleeper.


6.

It is my truth that change does not exist for me

and the cause of change is never mine due to my nondual nature.

Thus I possess neither merit nor sin, liberation nor bondage,

social class nor stage of life for I'm without a body.


7.

Beginningless and without attributes, I claim no action nor its results.

For I am the Supreme without a second.

As space is all-pervading yet untouched,

I permeate this body with my subtlety.


8.

Always and equally in all beings, I am Isvara, the Supreme Ruler.

Beyond the mortal and immortal, I am the highest and the ultimate.

Although that Supreme Self of Reality and Nondual Being,

I am mistaken to be otherwise by the nescience of ignorance.


9.

Detached from ignorance, imagination, and action,

the limitless Self is completely pure.

Endowed with the powers of seeing and such, I am nondual,

established in my true nature, and motionless like the sky.


10.

I, Parabrahman, Atman, with surest vision, see—

no one is born again, as the Vedas say.

When the seed is absent, there's no creation.

No fruit is born where there's no delusion.


11.

This is thus mine and that like this is yours;

I also alone oversee my world and not otherwise:

such is the delusion of people's imagination.

Eternally equal is Brahman in that auspicious nonduality.


12.

That nondual knowledge is exceedingly pure. 

The great ones thus experience neither sorrow nor delusion. 

In the absence of both, there's neither birth nor binding action. 

Such assuredness arises in the knowers of the Vedas.


13.

As in deep sleep while in the waking state is the one who doesn't see duality

while seeing through it to that nonduality.

Similarly is the one performing actions although actionless.

One is the knower of the Self and no other is the conclusion here.


14.

Thus this vision of supreme truth that's been declared

by me surely is the highest observation of Vedanta.

One is completely liberated if it is firmly understood.

As the sky is never stained, so is it here by action.




Bibliography

The Thousand Teachings trans. by A.J. Alston

Upadesa Sahasri trans. by Swami Jagadananda

A Thousand Teachings trans. by John Denton

A Thousand Teachings trans. by Sengaku Mayeda


Introductions

In the post-war years, western and western-inspired scholarship, notably that of Paul Hacker and Sengaku Mayeda, has tended to show that the only surviving independent work that can with safety be ascribed to Śaṃkara is the Upadeśa Sāhasrī or Thousand Teachings in both its prose and verse parts—though it would be incautious to suppose that there was finality in this judgement...

The independent works other than the Upadeśa Sāhasrī are not safe guides to the doctrine of the historical Śaṃkara, while the Upadeśa Sāhasrī itself is. Hence its importance today as a relatively compact statement by Śaṃkara of his own view, eminently suitable as an introduction to the inherently more diffuse work of the commentaries...

It is, however, not certain that either the prose or the verse parts of the Upadeśa Sāhasrī originally constituted a unity. The whole work is very possibly a compilation of short pieces that originally stood on their own...

Of the verse part, Chapters I, XVII, XVIII and XIX appear from their dedicatory verses to have been separate works originally. Chapters II to XVI, also, are most probably a compilation of works that were originally separate, as it is hard to explain the fact that they stand in ascending order of length as being due to mere chance...

~Alston


The Upadesasahasri consists of two parts, one in verse and the other in prose. The verse or Metrical Part (Padyabandha) comprises nineteen chapters (prakarana). Manuscripts indicate that the two parts were regarded as independent works, as it were, and studied or commented upon separately. They also suggest the possibility that any single chapter could be selected, copied, and studied apart from the rest. This means that reading of the text may begin anywhere. 

~Mayeda


Sankara’s manner of exposition does not present us with the usual but avoidable additional difficulty which is obscurity of expression. He wrote magnificent works, both in prose and verse; and all of them are marked by depth of thought and lucidity of language. 

Among his major works are the great commentaries on what are known as the three canons of Vedanta, viz., the principal Upanishads, the Bhagavad-gita, and the Brahma-sutra, and such independent manuals as the Upadesasahasri and the Vivekachudamani. 

The quintessence of the philosophy of Sankara is stated in the following words which constitute a half-verse in Sanskrit; ‘‘The Absolute Spirit is the reality; the world of appearance is illusory; the so-called individual soul is the Absolute itself, and no other.”

~Mahadevan






Upadesa Sahasri 10.14 Translations

itīdam uktam paramārtha-darśanam mayā hi vedānta-viniścitam paraṃ vimucyate ’smin yadi niścito bhaven na lipyate vyoma iveha karmabhiḥ 

[14] In these words I have proclaimed the nature of vision of the highest reality, the supreme conclusion of Vedānta. If a man becomes convinced of it he is liberated. Like the ether, he is no longer tainted by activity here in this world. ~Alston

14. This Right knowledge described by me is the highest because it is ascertained in the Vedântas. One becomes liberated and unattached (to actions) like the ether if one is perfectly convinced of this Truth. ~Jagadananda

14. This view which has been declared by me from the stand¬ point of the highest truth is the supreme [view] as ascertained in the Vedanta. If a man has firm belief in it, he is released and not stained by actions,10 as others are. ~Mayeda


My transcreation in progress:

Thus this vision of supreme truth that's been declared

by me surely is the highest observation of Vedanta.

One is completely liberated if it is firmly understood.

As the sky is never stained, so is it here by action.



All transcreations to date:

Transcreating Upadesa Sahasri Verse Chapter 10 dṛśi-svarūpa paramārtha-darśanam



Google:

Line 1: itīdam uktam paramārtha-darśanam
  • iti (इति): thus / in this manner
  • idam (इदम्): this
  • uktam (उक्तम्): spoken / declared / taught
  • parama (परम): supreme / highest
  • artha (अर्थ): reality / purpose / truth
  • darśanam (दर्शनम्): vision / philosophy / realization
Line 2: mayā hi vedānta-viniścitam paraṃ
  • mayā (मया): by me
  • hi (हि): indeed / surely (used for emphasis)
  • vedānta (वेदान्त): Vedanta (the end/essence of the Vedas)
  • viniścitam (विनिश्चितम्): thoroughly ascertained / conclusively proven
  • param (परम्): ultimate / highest
Line 3: vimucyate ’smin yadi niścito bhaven
  • vimucyate (विमुच्यते): is completely liberated / freed
  • asmin (अस्मिन्): in this (supreme truth/self)
  • yadi (यदि): if
  • niścitaḥ (निश्चितः): firm / convinced / resolute
  • bhavet (भवेत्): should be / becomes
Line 4: na lipyate vyoma iveha karmabhiḥ
  • na (न): not
  • lipyate (लिप्यते): is tainted / smeared / affected
  • vyoma (व्योम): sky / space
  • iva (इव): like / just as
  • iha (इह): here / in this world
  • karmabhiḥ (कर्मभिः): by actions / by karmas


Upadesa Sahasri 10.13 Translations

suṣuptavaj jāgrati yo na paśyati dvayam tu paśyann api cādvayatvataḥ tathā ca kurvann api niṣkriyaś ca yaḥ sa ātma-vin nānya itīha niścayaḥ 

[13] He who, though seeing duality when awake, yet on account of his awareness of non-duality does not see it as if he were asleep, and who is apparently active yet really actionless for the same reason—he alone is a knower of the Self. Such is the settled conclusion of our tradition. ~Alston

13. It is the conclusion here (in the Vedântas) that one who, though perceiving16the world of duality in the waking state, does not,17like a man in deep sleep,18 perceive it owing to duality being negated, and who is (really) actionless even when (apparently) acting, is a man of Self-knowledge ; but no one else is so. ~Jagadananda

13. He who, in the waking state, like a man in the state ofdeep sleep, does not see duality, though [actually] seeing, because of his non-duality, and similarly he who, though [in fact] acting, is actionless—he [only]is the knower ofAtman, and nobody else. This is the firm conclusion here [in the Vedanta]. ~Mayeda


My Transcreation:

As in deep sleep while in the waking state is the one who doesn't see duality

while seeing through it to that nonduality.

Similarly is the one performing actions although actionless.

One is the knower of the Self and no other is the conclusion here.






All transcreations to date:

Transcreating Upadesa Sahasri Verse Chapter 10 dṛśi-svarūpa paramārtha-darśanam



Google:

Line 1: suṣuptavaj jāgrati yo na paśyati dvayam
  • suṣuptavad (सुषुप्तवत्) = like in deep sleep (where no world or duality is perceived)
  • jāgrati (जाग्रति) = while in the waking state
  • yaḥ (यः) = who
  • na paśyati (न पश्यति) = does not see
  • dvayām (द्वयम्) = duality / multiplicity / two-ness
Line 2: tu paśyann api cādvayatvataḥ

  • tu (तु) = but / however
  • paśyann (पश्यन्) = seeing (physically perceiving objects)
  • api (अपि) = even though / although
  • ca (च) = and
  • advayatvataḥ (अद्वयत्वतः) = due to the state of absolute non-duality (advaita)

  • Line 3: tathā ca kurvann api niṣkriyaś ca yaḥ
    • tathā (तथा) = in the same manner / likewise
    • ca (च) = and
    • kurvann (कुर्वन्) = performing actions
    • api (अपि) = even though / although
    • niṣkriyaḥ (निष्क्रियः) = actionless / free from the sense of agency
    • ca (च) = and
    • yaḥ (यः) = who
  • Line 4: sa ātma-vin nānya itīha niścayah
  • saḥ (सः) = he
  • ātma-vit (आत्मवित्) = the knower of the Self / the enlightened one
  • na (न) = not
  • anyaḥ (अन्यः) = another / anyone else
  • iti (इति) = thus
  • iha (इह) = here (in this world / in Vedanta)
  • niścayaḥ (निश्चयः) = the firm conclusion / certainty