Isavasya 14 Translation Fantasia

sambhūtiṁ ca vināśaṁ ca yastadvedobhayagṁsaha,

vināśena mṛtyuṁ tīrtvā sambhūtyāmṛtamaśnute.

सम्भूतिम् – impersonal God; च – and; विनाशम् – personal God; च – and; यः – who; तत् – that; वेद – knows; उभयग्म् – both; सह – together; विनाशेन – by personal God; मृत्युम् – death; तीर्त्वा – crossing; सम्भूत्या – by impersonal God; अमृतम् – immortality; अश्नुते – enjoys, obtains

He who knows that both the unmanifested prakriti and the manifested Hiranyagarbha should be worshipped together, overcomes death by the worship of Hiranyagarbha and obtains immortality through devotion to prakriti.

The result of combining the two kinds of worship described in the text is, first, the attainment of supernatural powers through devotion to Hiranyagarbha, and second, the attainment of immortality (relative) by merging in prakriti. The attainment of this immortality is the culmination of the efforts of a man or a god. It is the highest achievement in the relative universe.

~Nikhilananda

He who worships the impersonal God and the personal God together, overcomes death through the worship of the personal and obtains immortality through the worship of the impersonal.

Here Śrī Śaṅkara takes sambhūti to mean the ‘primordial matter’ (mahat tattvaṁ) which we may call as prakṛti or nature, which is not in its expression an effect but the very cause for the entire manifested prakṛti. By the term asambhūti, Śaṅkara understands as the kārya (effects), the saguṇa Brahman, the conditioned reality. We need not go into the philosophical hair-splitting and exhaust ourselves at present.

One very satisfying explanation I had heard was from my Gurudev, Śrī Swami Tapovana Mahārāja. It beautifully reconciles this confusing contradiction. He suggested to us to recognise sambhūti and sambhava as meaning the birth of a new spiritual life, and asambhūti and vināśam as referring to the cessation and destruction cessation of the creation of new vāsanās and the total destruction of the entire existing vāsanās.

~Chinmayananda

He who knows at the same time both the Unmanifested (the cause of manifestation) and the destructible or manifested, he crosses over death through knowledge of the destructible and attains immortality through knowledge of the First Cause (Unmanifested). 

This particular Upanishad deals chiefly with the Invisible Cause and the visible manifestation, and the whole trend of its teaching is to show that they are one and the same, one being the outcome of the other hence no perfect knowledge is possible without simultaneous comprehension of both.

By work, by making the mind steady and by following the prescribed rules given in the Scriptures, a man gains wisdom. By the light of that wisdom he is able to perceive the Invisible Cause in all visible forms. Therefore the wise man sees Him in every manifested form. They who have a true conception of God are never separated from Him. They exist in Him and He in them.

~Paramananda

He who understands the manifest and the unmanifest both together, crosses death through the unmanifest and attains life eternal through the manifest.

To be absorbed in the world around without turning to the principle at the base of it is one extreme; to be absorbed in the contemplation of the transcendent infinite indifferent to the events of the manifested world because they are likely to disturb inward serenity and self-complacency is another extreme. This verse asks us to lead a life in the manifested world with a spirit of non¬ attachment, with the mind centred in the unmanifest. We must live in this world without being choked by it. We must centre our thoughts in the eternal remembering that the eternalis the soul of the temporal. 

~Radhakrishnan

He who understands the manifest and the unmanifest together, crosses death.

This is said because one could otherwise become one-sided and forget the world and concentrate only on the unmanifest! This is almost impossible because it requires a great deal of physical, mental, and psychological preparation. 

Understanding the unmanifest and the manifest together

means to live where you are, and simultaneously go on with your studies and your search for the Truth, giving enough importance to the manifest as well as the unmanifest, until you begin to understand the truth that the Supreme Being is the only living reality, and is all-pervading.

So, one has to go carefully. Keep the manifest in view, keep the unmanifest in view, balance the two and move forward. When one is completely convinced, then one can drop the manifest. In fact, you do not even have to drop it. Maya pushes you out; you don’t have to even try!

~Sri M